| Player | Position | School | Year |
| David Macias | INF | Vanderbilty University | 2005 |
| Dave Mattle (*) | OF | Kent State University | 1999-2001 |
| Josh Mayle | P | Kent State University | 2001-2002 |
| Rory Meister | P | The Ohio State University | 2004-2005 |
| Brad Miller (*) | INF | Ball State University | 2004-2005 |
| Jon Miller | P | Kent State University | 2004 |
| Adam Moss | INF | Miami of Ohio University | 1999 |
| *Erik Morrison | P | Ball State University | 2004 |
| Lee Morrison (%) | OF | Bowling Green State University | 1999-2000 |
| Alec Moss | INF | Xavier University | 2002 |
| Mike Muzi | P | Bowling Green State University | 1999 |
| Davis Myers | INF | Georgia Tech | 2000 |
| Walt Novosel (*) | P | Ohio University | 2000 |
| Eric O'Brien | P | Kent State University | 2000 |
| Casey O'Quinn | INF | Troy State University | 2001 |
| Angelo Palazetti | P | Western Michigan University | 1999 |
| Terry Pettorini | INF | The Ohio State University | 2000 |
| Darren Pitchford | P | UC Santa Barbara | 2003 |
| Ryan Quirello | INF | Gardner-Webb University | 2003 |
| Matt Raih | P | Xavier University | 1999 |
| *Nolen Reimold | OF | Bowling Green State University | 2003 |
| Kyle Roberson | OF | Winthrop University | 2002 |
| Drew Roberts | INF | Xavier University | 2004 |
| Casey Rosendahl | P | University of Dayton | 1999 |
| Adam Russell (*) | P | Ohio University | 2003 |
| Dustin Sampson (%) | P | Kent State University | 1999-2001 |
| Kendall Schlabach | OF | Youngstown State University | 2002 |
| Chris Schmidt | OF | West Virginia University | 2000-2001 |
| Andrew See (%) | OF/P | Ohio University | 2000 |
| Ryan Sellman | P | Youngstown State University | 2005 |
| Mike Shaeffer | P | University of Iowa | 2000 |
| % Eric Shaffer | P | Youngstown State University | 2004-2005 |
| Jordan Simo | P | East Los Angles C.C. | 2003 |
| Aaron Smigelski | INF/P | Ohio University | 2002-2003 |
| Jonathan Smart | P | Youngstown State University | 2002 |
| Matt Smith | OF/P | Cleveland State University | 2001 |
| Pat Smith | INF | Cleveland State University | 2002 |
| Alex Stewart | INF | Murray State University | 2004 |
| Ryan Streb | P | Bowling Green State University | 1999 |
| Mike Sullivan * | OF | Ball State University | 2004-2005 |
| %Nick Szczur | P | University of Toledo | 2004 |
*Drafted by Major League Baseball
%Drafted by an Independent Team